Alternatives to Marriage Update:
November/December
2001
In this issue:
Around the Alternatives to Marriage Project
1) Tell the Government Marriage Isn't a Solution to Poverty
2) Boston ATMPers Party, Raise Funds
3) New Gay and Lesbian
Legal Guide in Stock Now
In the Media
Book Buzz: Questions Before "I
Do": Five Books
Heaps of Thank You's
Community Announcement
Tidbits
Sizzling Statistics
News From the United States
News From
Around the World
Domestic Partner News (U.S.)
Quoteworthy
Around the Alternatives to Marriage
Project
1) Tell the Feds Marriage Isn't Solution to Poverty
The Department
of Health and Human Services is currently seeking public comment as its
re-evaluates the welfare laws that make up Temporary Assistance to Needy
Families Program (TANF). This is a chance to explain to government officials the
dangers of programs that promote or reward marriage. Such programs risk
punishing unmarried people and their families, penalizing people who can't marry
(such as same-sex couples), trapping victims of domestic violence, and
disregarding all Americans' right to form their families in a way that works
best for them. Comments should be about your own experiences with TANF either as
a recipient, former recipient, service provider, advocate or policy expert, and
must be submitted by November 30, 2001. You can read more and submit comments online.
2) Boston ATMPers Party, Raise Funds
The Alternatives
to Marriage Project's Boston houseparty at the home of Roland and Carol Glenn
was a decided success! Dozens of local ATMP supporters nibbled, chatted, shared
with the group what inspired them about ATMP, and made generous contributions in
support of social justice for unmarried people. Let ATMP be your excuse to throw
a party! It can be a small dinner party, an elegant cocktail party, a wild dance
party, or anything else. You invite the guests (we can help you with invitations
if you want), let them know your event will benefit ATMP, and put your hosting
skills to work. The event is a regular party, with a brief section where you
tell your friends a little about all the great work this organization does and
encourage them to make a donation of whatever they can afford (we can help you
with this section, too). Everyone wins: your friends get a great party and learn
about a cool group, while ATMP receives contributions that make our work
possible. Contact us to discuss the possibilities!
3) New Gay and Lesbian Legal Guide in Stock
Now
Our shipment of the brand new 2001 edition of the Legal Guide for Lesbian and
Gay Couples has just arrived! Nolo's self-help legal guides are the best we've
seen -- we sell them because we think they're important, and many people had
trouble finding them in bookstores. This 10th edition includes chapters on
parenting, medical and financial matters, buying a home together, wills and
estate planning, and other issues. Nolo also publishes Living Together, a guide
covering the same issues for different-sex unmarried couples. Both books can be
purchased online . They make
great holiday gifts for the unmarried couples you love!
In the Media
Utne Reader Quotes This Newsletter!
The November/December issue of
the Utne Reader cites the Alternatives to Marriage Update in a news blurb about
a gay couple who where one partner adopted the other since they couldn't get
married. We originally reported the item in our June issue. Experts say adoption
is not a good substitute for marriage for many reasons, including the fact that
divorce is not an option.
Six Florida ATMPers Featured
Three
sets of ATMPers -- Kelly Wade and Tim Arnel, Karen Hamilton and Alex Procho, and
Linda Tablada and Abel Rodriguez -- brought to life an article in the South
Florida Sun-Sentinel about couples who choose notto marry. The three couples
have varied perspectives (Wade and Arnel chose to have a child together without
marrying, for example while Tablada's 6 year old daughter from a previous
marriage does not know her mother is unmarried), but all seem to agree that what
makes relationships thrive or fail is not legal marital status.
Paper
Explores DP Benefits for Non-Gays
Executive Director Dorian Solot was
quoted in an article on domestic partner benefits in the East Bay Business
Times. Solot pointed out that although these benefits are often discussed solely
as a "gay issue," 90% of employers offering them make them available to
different-sex couples as well as same-sex ones. She said, " The most important
reason to offer [them] to both same-sex and opposite-sex couples is that it's a
matter of equal pay for equal work. The gender of people involved shouldn't
matter."
Early Childhood Educators Integrate Support for Diverse
Families
In its issue on families, the New York State Association for the
Education of Young Children newsletter quoted a long excerpt of our Affirmation
of Family Diversity and encouraged readers to add their names. The article
challenged early childhood educators to consider ways to be inclusive of the
diverse families with whom they work. You can read some of these articles:
"Many couples aren't tying the knot," South
Florida Sun-Sentinel
"'Other' domestic partners feel shut out," East
Bay Business Times
Book Buzz
Questions Before "I Do": Five Books
2002 Questions and Answers for Lovers: Fun, Romantic, and Revealing, by Cyndi Haynes and Dale Edwards (Adams Media Corporation, 2000)
Don't You Dare Get Married Until You Read This: The Book of Questions for
Couples, by Corey Donaldson (Three Rivers Press, 2001)
The Hard Questions: 100 Essential Questions To Ask Before You Say "I Do", by Susan Piver (Jeremy P. Tarcher/Putnam, 2000)
How Can I Be Sure? Questions To Ask Before You Get Married, by Bob Phillips (Harvest House Publishers, 1999)
The Marital Compatibility Test: Hundreds of Questions for Couples to
Answer Together, by Susan Adams (Addicus Books, 2000)
Reviewed by Marshall Miller
It's time for an evening with "the book." You cuddle up with your partner on
the sofa, turn to him or her, flip open a page, and read, "What does my family
do that annoys you?" Or perhaps you land on a different page and ask, "Are you
involved in any criminal activities right now?" Welcome to the genre of books of
questions to ask before getting married. They are based on the idea that if
you're going to get married (or, perhaps, make the decision to live together),
it's better to talk now and know each other well than be surprised later. The
questions could just as easily apply to unmarrieds who want to get to know each
other all over again. Of the five books surveyed, Corey Donaldson's is the best,
particularly given that his 500 question list was created by asking 1,500
people, "If you could only ask one question of your partner before you got
married, what would it be?" The resulting list is insightful as well as
downright amusing.
It's great to have a book as an excuse to pepper your partner with questions
ranging from, "Have you ever been in a porn film?" to "What is your deepest,
darkest secret?" Susan Adams has a different take, focusing instead on some of
the smaller, but perhaps even more aggravating details of life. There is, of
course, that pesky toilet seat, but also whether you and your partner agree on
the use of a bath mat (important/unimportant/a hassle) or on whether "fruits and
vegetables are appropriate sexual aids" (true/false). Susan Piver's and Cyndi
Haynes' pocket-sized books are accessible but a bit shallow; and Bob Phillips
writes from a Christian perspective. Overall, it's worth giving at least one of
these books a try, whether you're planning to marry or not, because there's no
harmin asking, right? [For another perspective, see our article, "Ten Ways To Improve
Your Chances for a Good Marriage After Cohabitation,".]
Heaps of Thank You's
As a grassroots organization, ATMP's work is done by countless volunteers around the country.
Thanks to John Kilguss for his months of work processing the surveys that people fill out every day on our website, and for his assistance every other month helping mail the paper version of the Alternatives to Marriage Update to those who don't have email access.
A wonderful group of volunteers at Franklin Skilled Nursing and Rehabilitation, coordinated by Linda Bonneau, also help with each paper Update mailing. Thank you to computer whiz Glenn Strauss for donating his time to set up a system that automatically processes the survey data, saving other volunteers hundreds of hours of work a year!
Many thanks to Piti Itharat, who now maintains our Stories page, where people who visit the website can share their experiences (and their photos, if they
want).
Continuing thank you's to Wendy Layton, last summer's intern, who has returned to Smith College but generously continues to prepare each month's online Update to be posted.
Thank you to the "many hands make light work" mailing party crew who helped prepare our fundraising letter: Pete Chvany, LouAnn Cossette, Mark Dulcey, Martha Ehrenfeld, Mark Fang, Woody Glenn, Pepper Greene, Alan Hamilton, John Kilguss, John Lapham, Rev. David Olson, Sarah Rowley, Nick Willis, and Laura and the two Andrews from Boston University.
And finally, thank you to the host committee for last month's fundraising houseparty in Boston: David Abbott, Johanna Bates & Colin Mitchell, Linda Blair, Nicholas Danforth, Martha Ehrenfeld & Lauren Wedam, Roland & Carol Glenn, Woody Glenn, Alan Hamilton, Pepper Greene, & Pete Chvany, Buzz Harris, Karl Heinemann & Beverly Slayton, John Lapham, Emma Lathan, Victoria
Medaglia and Paul Holland, Robyn Ochs & Peg Preble, Jeremy Pittman, Sarah Rowley, Ellyn Ruthstrom, Anne Slepian & Christopher Mogil, and Pam Williams.
Community Announcement
Alternative Families Organization Announces Positions
Alternative Family Matters, a Boston-based organization addressing lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgendered family issues, is seeking two part-time employees. One is a Social Worker/Counselor for the LGBT Aunts and Uncles Program; the other is a Conception Connection Computer Commander. To learn more about the organization go to Alternative Families. To request more detailed information about the openings, contact Jenifer Firestone at
This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
or (617) 576-6788.
Tidbits
Never-Married Women Healthier in Old Age
According to The Scotsman, a long-term study of 15,000 middle-aged men and women found that women who had never married and never given birth had the best chance for good health in their later years. At the thirty-year followup point, Professor Mary Gilhooly of the University of Paisley she found most of the unmarried women did not fit the spinster stereotype, but that "they were dynamic and leading interesting lives with very strong social circles."
British Wives Offered 'Divorce Loan'
A London firm of solicitors and a private bank have created a loan for women who are unable to divorce because of the costs involved. The loan is being offered by the Alternative Matrimonial and Litigation Funding Ideas.
People Magazine Notes Single Moms Accepted
An article in People Magazine pointed out that the recent plotline of the popular TV show "Friends," in which a pregnant Rachel turns down Joey's offer of marriage, did not provoke an outcry. The magazine compared the episode with Dan Quayle's outrage when Murphy Brown had a
baby without a husband nine years ago. On "Friends," Rachel said, "I'm not
looking for a husband."
Sizzling Statistics
Thanks to Lisa Parkinson for her help compiling the news, statistics, and tidbits in this issue!
Mississippi, South Carolina, Louisiana Lead in Unmarried Moms
One in three never-married women in South Carolina has children, moving the state to second in the nation, new census figures show. In 1990 21% of never-married women had a child; this has
risen to 33%. South Carolina follows only Mississippi in the rankings. The other top five states, in order, are Louisiana, the District of Columbia, and New
Mexico.
Marriage and Non-Marriage in Scotland
A study of
30,000 Scottish households found that just over a fifth of adults have never
married, and 6% are cohabiting (compared with 2% in the U.S.). Fifty-six percent
of adults are married (compared with 52% in the U.S.), and 20% of households
with children contain unmarried parents. Young British See Marriage as Optional
A survey of nearly 2,000 people youth ages 11 to 16 found that many see marriage
as a "choice rather than a must." The most popular option was the prospect of
living with a partner with the possibility of marriage, with some young British
women feeling there was no point in getting married at all. Many want to wait
until they are older to marry.
News From the United States
Pataki Offers Limited Help to Sept. 11th Unmarried
Partners
Governor George Pataki issued an executive order that same-sex
and different-sex partners of people killed by terrorists should qualify for
Crime Victims Board benefits equal to those of married couples. However, the
order does not allow unmarried partners to claim state workers' compensation
benefits, federal benefits such as social security survivor's benefits, or
victim's assistance program benefits.
North Carolina Cohabitor Loses
Child Custody
A judge found a North Carolina man guilty of a rarely
enforced 1805 law against cohabitation, but acquitted his former live-in partner
of the same charge. The woman was seeking custody of her two daughters (she was
separated from her husband), but the judge, an ordained Methodist minister, used
the law to justify giving custody to her husband. She was not punished because
there was no evidence she had had sex with her cohabiting partner; the partner
was ordered to pay court costs of $90. Although cohabitation laws are rarely
enforced, they are occasionally invoked when people are involved with the legal
system for a different reason (in this case, seeking custody of children). A list of states where cohabitation
is illegal.
West Virginia Considers Eliminating Marriage Bonus
West Virginia is considering eliminating the $100 per month incentive
that welfare recipients there can get for being married. The state is predicted
to run a $90 million deficit by 2003. The director of the Office of Family
Support said, "The field staff doesn't believe it works. They don't think people
are rushing out and getting married for $100 per month." West Virginia is the
only state to offer a marriage incentive for welfare recipients. The
Alternatives to Marriage Project strongly opposes financial incentives for
marriage, because they often punish those who can't or choose not to marry, as
well as encouraging people to stay in abusive marriages.
Pennsylvania
Considers Legal Recognition of Partner-Child Relationship
A provision in
a proposed Pennsylvania adoption law would allow a child to be adopted by a
parent's unmarried partner, regardless of that person's gender, if the other
parent's custody rights have been terminated. Senator Stewart Greenleaf, who
sponsored the bill said "We begin the process ... to achieve an adoption law
that serves children in need of stable, loving homes." The Alternatives to
Marriage Project believes that legal protections for unmarried families are an
important part of helping these families stay strong and stable. We believe that
in some situations both children and parents would benefit from the kind of
adoption reform proposed in Pennsylvania.
News From Around the World
British Bill Would Provide Rights for Partners
A proposed British law, Relationships (Civil Registration) Bill, could allow
local authorities to formally register unmarried couples, giving them rights
similar to married couples. The Law Society supports the move. The bill was
approved by 179 votes to 59, but according to the BBC, due to a lack of
parliamentary time it is unlikely to become law.
Unmarrieds Should
Have Right to Adopt, says British Agency
A British adoption group says
that same-sex and different-sex couples who live together in stable
relationships should be given the same rights to adopt children jointly as
married couples have, an adoption group said. A growing number of legislators
are backing the British Agencies for Adoption and Fostering campaign, and a poll
found 68% of adults in support. Experts say the current adoption barriers are
silly at a time when 40% of British children are born to unmarried parents. In
the U.S., laws and policies about unmarried partners and adoption vary from
state to state and agency to agency. However, in most places it is possible for
single parents and unmarried same-sex and different-sex couples to adopt.
Chile Could Lift Ban on Divorce
Chile is one of the few
countries in the world that still bans divorce and over the past 90 years, 12
attempts to end the ban have failed. However, in 1997 Congress passed a law to
permit divorce. The law must still be approved by the Senate, and the outcome
will hang on one or two votes. Indonesian Couple Held for Selling Fake Marriage
Certificates Immigration officers detained an Indonesian couple involved in
producing and selling fake Indonesian marriage certificates. Seventeen
certificates were found in a chicken coop behind the house where the officers
had trapped the couple. Initial investigations revealed the certificates were
used by immigrants to "register" marriages to avoid being caught for committing
khalwat (close proximity).
Turkey May Increase Rights for Women &
Unmarried
Vying for membership of the European Union, Turkey is revising
its 75-year-old civil code. Among many proposed changes, draft language in the
new code would give women the right to help make decisions about children and
her home, and to decide to work without her husband's consent. It would grant
the children of unmarried parents the same inheritance rights as others, and
give single people the right to adopt.
Same Sex Couples Given Equal
Rights in Victoria, Canada
The language in 43 Victorian acts of
parliament has been updated to be inclusive of same-sex couples. Parliament
moved to amend language in 14 acts in accordance with the government's
anti-discrimination legislation, bringing the total of amended acts to 43. The
legislation adopted the terms "spouse," "domestic partner," and "partner."
Domestic Partner News (U.S.)
Procter & Gamble, Raytheon, Fremont Police, Others
Add DP Benefits
Procter and Gamble has announced it will offer domestic
partner benefits to the same-sex partners of its employees. The policy is an
expansion of an earlier decision to provide benefits to household dependents
beyond spouses, such as grandparents and grandchildren. Raytheon, the nation's
third largest defense contractor, announced that it will extend health insurance
and other benefits to the same-sex domestic partners of its employees. The
benefits will include medical, vision, dental and life insurance, family,
medical and bereavement leave, retirement and survivorship benefits, long-term
care insurance and dependent child scholarships. Fremont, California is making
optional medical benefits for domestic partners available to police officers.
The state has been offering domestic partner benefits for state employees and
public agencies for approximately three years. Other employers that have
recently begun to offer DP benefits, according to the Human Rights Campaign:
Applera Corporation, East Hartford Board of Education, Family Services of King
County, Kramer Levin Naftalis & Frankel LLP, Litchfield Board of Education,
Metropolitan Life Insurance, Metropolitan Opera Association, Port of Oakland,
Project Renewal, Raytheon, Regional School District #19 Board of Education, and
UnumProvident Corporation.
Davis Signs Domestic Partner Bill
California Governor Gray Davis signed legislation providing about a dozen
rights that married couples receive to registered same-sex and senior citizen
different-sex domestic partners in California. The bill lets partners who
register make medical decisions for their incapacitated partners, sue for
wrongful death, adopt a partner's child and will property to a partner. More information about
domestic partner registries and a link to California's registry.
Atlanta May Require City Contractors to Offer Domestic Partner
Benefits
The Atlanta City Council is considering a measure that would
require private employers seeking contracts with the city to provide domestic
partner benefits. San Francisco was the first city to approve such an ordinance,
which went into effect in 1997. Since then, Seattle, Los Angeles, Berkeley,
California, Tumwater, Washington, and San Mateo County, California, have enacted
similar measures.
Quoteworthy
"There are special programs to help family members when
tragedy strikes. However, in the military's eyes, we are not a family, so
support is not available to me. ... To the military, I am just the floozy that
their soldier is shacking up with. It makes me sad that when I need to turn to
my fiance for support, he is not there for me. But he is supporting the
military. Can I then turn to the military for support? No. I have no one to turn
to." - Hannah Peterson, whose unmarried partner was deployed in the military,
from WBUR's
Radio Diaries, October 5, 2001
|